The four kinds
The first three are never normal and cannot be switched off.
Why 4xx is opt-in
A 4xx is usually the caller’s own bug, which is exactly why an integration tool should be able to catch it. But an endpoint where a 401 is the normal answer would page you all day.client_error_rate is the share of requests to one endpoint family that must be 4xx before one is reported. Below 20 requests to a family no rate is claimed at all, because the first 4xx is a rate of 1.0 and means nothing.
The recording is the reproduction
An incident forces its recording to disk regardless ofsampling.rate. Sampling it away would leave you with an alert pointing at something you cannot run.
Listing them
incidents is a reader, not a gate: it exits 0 whether or not it found anything. The reproducible until line appears when retention.max_age_hours bounds how long the recording stays on disk. --format json always carries total_matching and truncated. See pikopod incidents.
Reproducing one
pikopod incidents export <fp> writes a bundle that reproduce accepts anywhere. See Reproduce.